One drawing, two products, and why one approval was not enough
Sharing a drawing across two products in the same range looks like a saving. It becomes a problem at the point where the second product is loaded into a unit approved against the first.
Illustrative procurement scenario. This is not a customer case, and no outcome or performance figure is claimed.

The situation
A range has two products built on the same drawing: same footprint, same tier count, same sheet and finish. One is approved on a sample. Both are released to production, and the second product is loaded into the same unit.
The unit holds the second product, but it does not behave the same way. One sits further forward, so the load moves toward the front edge. A different pack depth means the front lip no longer does the job it was drawn for.
What one approval actually covers
A sample approval covers the configuration that was on the table: that drawing revision, that sheet, that thickness, that joint, that pack. It is evidence about one combination, not a certificate for the design.
Two products sharing a drawing still differ in the things that matter to a display:
- Packed weight, which decides the load on the tier and the base
- Centre of gravity, which decides whether the unit tips when a shopper lifts one pack out of the front row
- Handling frequency, which decides how much wear the edge and the joint take
- Pack depth, which decides whether the front lip still retains the product
What an approval record should name
The record should name the drawing revision, the sheet grade and thickness, the edge finish, the fixing method, the packed weight, the units per carton, and the checks that were actually performed: fit, movement, removal, stability and visible damage limits.
Then it should name who signed it and on which sample. A record that says only approved is not a record; it cannot be reordered from and it cannot be defended later.
The rule that prevents the problem
One record per product family, not one per drawing. If the physical components are identical and only fragrance, colour or artwork changes, the signed pack can stand as the reference. If the product, the pack, the sheet, the joint, the fixing or the delivery route changes, the pack is reviewed before the next run.
That single rule turns protecting the product into a repeatable purchasing decision instead of an assumption.
Send this in the RFQ
- Every product that will go into the unit, with packed weight and pack depth
- Which of those products will be loaded at the same time on the same counter
- Whether the shopper removes product or staff restock it
- The name of the person who will sign the approval, and against which sample