What each material is good at, in one line
PMMA, sold as acrylic, gives the best optical clarity and the best polished edge, which is why it dominates cosmetic and jewellery display. PS is cheaper and stiffer for the same thickness but is brittle and can craze. PC is the toughest of the four and resists impact, at the cost of clarity and scratch resistance. PETG forms and bends without cracking and tolerates rough handling, with slightly lower clarity than PMMA. See acrylic against PETG.
- PMMA: clarity and edge finish, the default for premium display.
- PS: cost and stiffness, suitable for short-life and printed units.
- PC: impact resistance where the unit will be abused.
- PETG: forming and folding, and tolerance of handling.
Clarity is not one property
Clarity combines light transmission, haze and how the material looks at an edge. PMMA transmits light with very low haze and polishes to a glass-like edge, which is what makes a thick acrylic display read as premium. PS starts close but ages worse. PC has a slight warm tint and a softer surface that scratches into visible haze. PETG is clear in the sheet and shows a faint colour at a thick edge, which matters on a 10 mm base and not at all on a 2 mm divider.
- Ask for transmission and haze figures from the supplier datasheet, not adjectives.
- Judge clarity on the thickest section of the unit, not on a sample sheet.
- For a printed panel, clarity matters far less than stiffness and cost.
Impact: where the unit gets hit
Impact resistance is a property of the whole design, not only the plastic. A thin PMMA panel breaks where a bolt hole concentrates stress; the same panel in PC survives. PS cracks at a tight radius or a screw driven too close to an edge. The practical rule is to match the material to the abuse the unit will see: counter units in a jewellery store are handled gently, while a floor unit in a supermarket is kicked, trolley-hit and leaned on.
- Increase the radius at a corner before changing material; geometry is cheaper than a material upgrade.
- Keep fasteners away from an edge, and use washers to spread load.
- Specify PC where the unit is exposed to trolleys, cleaning equipment or public floors.
Bonding and chemical resistance decide more than buyers expect
Solvent bonding works well on PMMA and produces a joint that reads as one piece; the same solvents attack PS and can craze it, and PC is sensitive to many solvents and to some cleaners. PETG bonds with different adhesives and is more forgiving of a mechanical joint. Where a unit will be cleaned daily with an alcohol-based product, the choice of material and the choice of cleaner have to be agreed together.
- Ask which solvent or adhesive the factory uses for the specified material.
- Name the cleaning chemical that will be used in service.
- For PC and PS, prefer mechanical joints over solvent where possible.
Light stability: the window display problem
Clear plastics yellow under ultraviolet light, and how fast depends on the grade rather than the family name. A display that sits in a shop window for a year is a different specification from one that stands in a shaded interior. UV-stabilised grades exist for PMMA and PC and are worth asking about by name; a generic sheet may carry no light-stability claim at all.
- State the exposure: window, interior, or direct sun for part of the day.
- Ask for the grade name and any light-stability claim in writing.
- For long-life window units, plan a replacement cycle rather than assuming no change.
Cost ranking is stable, ratios are not
The order is broadly PS below PETG below PMMA below PC, but the ratios move with sheet thickness, grade, colour and the market, so any ratio quoted here would be stale. What matters for a buyer is which lines of the quotation respond to a material change, and that is worth asking directly: request the same drawing quoted in two materials and compare the difference against the change in service life. See what drives display cost.
- Ask for the same unit quoted in two materials.
- Weigh the difference against expected replacement rate, not unit price alone.
- Remember that thinner high-grade sheet can beat thicker low-grade sheet.
The decision in practice
For cosmetic, jewellery and fragrance display, PMMA is the default because the edge and the clarity are the product. For short-life promotional units and printed panels, PS is often the sensible choice, provided the joints are designed for its brittleness. For floor units in public spaces and for anything that will be knocked, PC earns its cost. For folded or formed parts and for units that must survive handling, PETG removes a class of cracking failures.
- Premium interior display: PMMA, cast, polished edges.
- Promotional or printed: PS, with generous radii.
- Public floor or high abuse: PC, mechanical joints.
- Formed or folded parts: PETG.
How this buyer content is maintained
Published and reviewed by Yiwu Zhuochao Plastic Products Co., Ltd. Company facts are checked against the assessed Alibaba supplier profile; product and process guidance is based on the supplier’s current manufacturing scope and project-review workflow. Commercial terms and performance statements are published only where the owner can support them. Third-party certification issued by Intertek (天祥集团) is documented on the certification page; unit prices are quoted per project and are not published.
Frequently asked questions
Is acrylic the same as PMMA?
PMMA is the polymer; acrylic is the common trade name for sheet made from it. The distinction that matters commercially is cast versus extruded sheet, because they machine and polish differently. Ask which one the quotation assumes, since both are sold as clear acrylic.
Can PS be used for a display that lasts years?
It can, but it is the wrong default. PS is brittle and more prone to crazing, so a long-life unit needs generous corner radii, fasteners kept away from edges and a joint design that does not rely on solvent. Where the unit will be cleaned often or handled roughly, PMMA or PC is the safer specification.
Which plastic should a window display use?
A UV-stabilised grade of PMMA or PC, agreed by grade name rather than by family. Every clear plastic changes under prolonged ultraviolet exposure, and the rate depends on the grade. If the display will sit in direct sun, plan for a replacement cycle and ask the supplier what light-stability claim the specified sheet actually carries.
